The Rider: A Guide to Watching It Like a Critic

The Rider emerged quietly in 2017 but swiftly asserted itself as a poignant reinvention of the American Western through the lens of contemporary tragedy and resilience. Directed by Chloé Zhao, who would later ascend to global acclaim with Nomadland, this film blurs the line between documentary and fiction, revealing a raw, lived-in portrait of the modern-day cowboy. Zhao’s use of non-professional actors, many of them playing versions of themselves, lends the film an authenticity that transcends typical genre tropes.

Set against the sweeping, empty plains of South Dakota's Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, The Rider eschews melodrama for a quiet meditation on identity after trauma. Its subdued tone and deliberate pacing demand patience but reward with profound emotional depth. This is not the flamboyant Western of yesteryear but a minimalist, poetic inquiry into masculinity, disability, and survival in an unforgiving landscape.

By focusing on Brady Jandreau, a real rodeo rider who suffered a catastrophic injury, Zhao channels his personal struggle into a universal story of loss and self-discovery. The film’s sparse dialogue and elliptical storytelling invite viewers into a contemplative space, where the silence between words often speaks louder than the words themselves.

Narrative Structure and Pacing

The Rider unfolds with a deliberate economy of plot that mirrors the rhythms of Brady's world. Instead of a conventional dramatic arc, the narrative drifts through moments of everyday life, punctuated by the challenges Brady faces in redefining himself outside the rodeo arena. The film resists easy resolutions, eschewing climactic confrontations for quiet, often ambiguous emotional beats.

This restrained pacing allows the audience to inhabit Brady’s internal landscape—his frustration, hope, and tentative attempts to build a new identity. The narrative structure feels episodic but cohesive, with each scene functioning as a vignette contributing to the overall portrait.

It is a slow burn, demanding engagement rather than passive consumption.

• Non-linear, vignette-like progression reflecting real life’s unpredictability
• Emphasis on internal conflict over external plot drivers
• Deliberate moments of silence and stillness punctuating the narrative
• Minimal exposition, relying on visual storytelling and subtext

Editing Choices and Rhythm

Editing in The Rider complements its narrative subtlety, employing long takes and naturalistic pacing that resist dramatic manipulation. The cuts are sparse and unobtrusive, allowing performances and landscapes to breathe. This approach aligns closely with Zhao’s documentary sensibilities, fostering intimacy and immersion.

Transitions between scenes often feel organic, with lingering shots that capture ambient sounds—the creak of saddles, rustling grass, or distant animal calls—heightening the film’s sensory realism. The editing rhythm is unhurried, contributing to the film's meditative atmosphere and emphasizing the protagonist’s slow emotional recovery.

• Long takes that foreground performance and environment
• Minimal cross-cutting, preserving the temporal flow of scenes
• Sound bridges and ambient noise used to link sequences naturally
• Editing choices that emphasize realism over narrative urgency

How the Film Has Aged

In the years since its release, The Rider has retained a quiet power, aging gracefully as both a time capsule of a specific community and a timeless exploration of resilience. Its focus on Indigenous life and the lived experience of Native Americans in contemporary America has become increasingly relevant amid ongoing conversations about representation and authenticity in cinema.

The film’s intimate, unvarnished portrayal avoids romanticizing the West, presenting instead a nuanced, often harsh reality that stands in stark contrast to the genre’s mythologized past. As audiences and critics continue to seek diverse perspectives, The Rider remains a vital work that both honors tradition and critiques its limitations.

Visual Language and Cinematography

Joshua James Richards’ cinematography is a masterclass in capturing the stark beauty and expansive solitude of the American plains. The film’s visual language is suffused with natural light and carefully composed frames that echo the vastness and isolation of Brady’s environment.

The landscape itself becomes a silent character, reflecting the protagonist’s internal struggle.

The palette is muted—earth tones dominate, grounding the film in realism. Close-ups of horses and faces are interspersed with sweeping wide shots, creating a rhythm that oscillates between intimacy and the grand, indifferent outdoors.

This visual contrast reinforces the tension between human vulnerability and the rugged terrain.

• Use of natural lighting to enhance authenticity and mood
• Wide shots emphasizing isolation and landscape’s enormity
• Close-ups that convey emotional subtlety and connection
• Earthy color palette reinforcing thematic concerns

Why the Film Still Matters

The Rider is significant not only for its storytelling but also for its ethical approach to casting and subject matter. By casting Brady Jandreau and others essentially as themselves, Zhao challenges traditional boundaries of fiction and documentary, fostering a rare collaborative process that respects lived experience.

This film disrupts Hollywood’s conventional portrayals of Native Americans and Western mythology, offering a grounded, contemporary perspective that resonates deeply. Its themes of identity, trauma, and healing reach beyond cultural specifics, speaking to anyone grappling with loss and the search for meaning.

Influence on Later Cinema

The quiet success of The Rider helped cement Chloé Zhao’s reputation as a major voice in American independent cinema and inspired a wave of films blending documentary and narrative techniques. Its intimate, character-driven style has influenced filmmakers interested in exploring marginalized communities with sensitivity and nuance.

The film’s hybrid approach—melding real people with scripted scenarios—has since become a touchstone in discussions about ethical storytelling, encouraging greater collaboration between filmmakers and subjects. Zhao’s later accolades, including her historic Oscar wins, owe much to the groundwork laid here.

• Popularized the docu-fiction hybrid in indie cinema
• Influenced depiction of Native American stories with authenticity
• Encouraged filmmakers to cast non-professionals for emotional truth
• Helped elevate American independent Westerns beyond genre clichés

Where It Leaves Us

The Rider closes not with resolution but with an open-ended meditation on survival and identity, leaving viewers immersed in the complexities of a life reshaped by fate. It invites reflection on what it means to reinvent oneself when the central passion of life is suddenly taken away.

Ultimately, the film is less about closure and more about perseverance—the quiet dignity in carrying on amidst loss. In an era saturated with spectacle, The Rider remains a quietly radical achievement: a tender, unflinching look at humanity’s fragile, stubborn heart.

Up for more Film History discoveries?

Deepen your understanding of Cinema — explore more Film Theory.

Barry Lyndon: Themes, Mood, and Visual Language

It's Such a Beautiful Day: Symbolism and Interpretation

All That Heaven Allows: Context, Themes, and Style

O Lucky Man!: A Complete Guide

Drugstore Cowboy: A Guide to Watching It Like a Critic

Inherent Vice: What to Notice on a Rewatch

Revisiting Love Streams: A Thoughtful Breakdown

The Bitter Tea of General Yen: A Film History Perspective

Kes: What Makes It a Classic

12…10